Open Source Licensing Resources

For clients: LOGIN to my database of open source licensing information.

 

 

 

  • The Open Source Alternative: Understanding Risks and Leveraging Opportunities
    The Open Source Alternative: Understanding Risks and Leveraging Opportunities
    by Heather J. Meeker
  • A Primer on Intellectual Property Licensing
    A Primer on Intellectual Property Licensing
    by Heather Meeker
  • The Next Wave of Technologies: Opportunities in Chaos
    The Next Wave of Technologies: Opportunities in Chaos
    by Phil Simon
Powered by Squarespace
« UK Government Open Source Policy | Main | Bruce Perens on the Busybox Case »
Wednesday
Jan272010

SourceForge versus the Export Laws

A news flurry has erupted over SourceForge's policy denying access to users in nations sanctioned by US export law.  A blog states that The Obama administration insisted that Sourceforge adopt this policy -- though the restriction in Sourceforge's terms of service has already been in place for many years.  Sourceforge, of course, is caught in the cross-fire between US export regulation and the open source definition.  But statements that such a policy contravenes open source licenses are misguided -- there are plenty of reasons why the rights granted under open source licenses may not be freely exerciseable: regulatory law, trademark law, patent law to name a few.  Those who are complaining about Sourceforge's actions are probably unaware of the regulations that apply to software, and that they used to be far more egregious before they were revised in the early 1990s.  But the kerfuffle points up that the regulatory policy of the US is counterintuitive and awkward to apply to software.  It strains belief that any nefarious actor would be truly thwarted by a technical limitation on downloading code to a certain location.
The language of Sourceforge's terms of use is standard in the on-line content industry, and if you read to the end, in almost every on line terms of service and end user license. 

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend